Skip to main content
THREE IN A ROW --PUCCINI'S WOMEN

Manon
Madame Butterfly
Turnadot

(Not on this year are Mimi/La Boheme and Tosca.)

What they all share—exotic (erotic?) appeal and emotional vulnerability.  

And they also made me wonder, what were the real women in Puccini’s life like.

It’s complicated. 

Puccini began an affair and had a son with a married woman, Elvira, in 1884. After
her husband was killed by the jealous husband of his lover in 1904, Elvira married Puccini.

 In 1909, Elvira accused  Doria, a maid, of being Puccini’s mistress.  Doria then committed suicide.  An autopsy showed she was a virgin. 

As a side note, Elvira was sentenced to 5 months in prison, which she did not have to
serve because Puccini took care of things.

While all of Puccini’s opera women end up dead,  Liu, the slave girl in Turnadot, is the only one who is not actively engaged in a physical love affair, like Mimi, Tosca, Butterfly and Manon. She takes the only way out early, by killing herself after singing of her love which can never be fulfilled in life.   

Verdi’s women don’t end up any better but they seem to have choices which Puccini does not give his characters.    Aida chooses to go back and suffocate in a tomb with her love, while Violetta gives up any hope of a healthy life in the country with her lover, to go back to Paris and die of consumption.  

Facts:  Puccini died in 1924.  Several composers have offered endings to the unfinished Turnadot. Documents found in 2007 reveal that it was really  Doria’s cousin Guilia who was Puccini’s mistress.  

Fancy: While there is no question that Liu is not going to get the prince for her husband, there is still lingering questions as to what exactly Turnadot herself is really about.  Did any of these real women figure into the mix of stories and librettos that Puccini worked with? Is the Ice Princess cold and calculating or covering up emotional neediness and  therefore inspiring men that she is so worth dying for in order for them to give her love.

Take your pick — the force of facts or the flights of fancy  —but Puccini certainly loved women and he gave the world some of the best loved in opera for the world to love.


WANT TO CHECK IT OUT:  SEE MADAME BUTTERFLY AT THE MET MOVIES ON APRIL 2

Popular posts from this blog

  Once is here again!   The Brooklyn Gallery Players reach into the treasure chest of great musicals to bring Once alive and on stage in Brooklyn (until to December 17, 2023). Director Mark Gallagher , and Music Directors David Fletcher and Brendon McCray have crafted a vibrant production, seamlessly integrating the 15 member cast in roles  as both actors and musicians. Set in Dublin, the  formula for the poignant love triangle  is simple. Patrick Newhart  plays Guy, an Irish musician who has given up  on love as he sings the award winning classic  Falling.  Newhart mastered the bombastic busking guitar style and performed each of his songs with intensity and passion Sophie Smith-Brody  is Girl,  a Czech woman  who will inspire him to try again both in  love and with music. Smith-Brody performed each of her disparate songs with aplomb,  from the opening classical piece to her plaintive solos – If You Want...
Read more
THE GREY SUIT SOCIETY   A STORY OF FAITH, FAMILY, DEVOTION, BETRAYAL AND…RATS? A message that might seem so obvious in real life turns into a magic moment of awareness when it is takes to the stage with talented directors and a fine cast. Carlos Heredia is the actor, director and writer who with David Fletcher as music director has brought together a group of actors for a family friendly opera. Together they sounded as good as the show’s beautiful theme of peace. Who is the star of a show that is about family and devotion?   Leading the cast, is Analia Heredia as Nia who must go against society’s grain, to bring human hypocrisy into the light.   As she hopes to move out of the shadows in to a bright new world, her family includes Claudillea Holloway as Jelani,  Georgia Fender as Etana,  Sonya Rice as Achi, Carly Ameling as Jane,   Codie Milford as Omari,  Liz Neitge as Janna,  andTiana Markman as Dini. The “others” are ...
Read more
From EUGENE ONEGIN  to  DER ROSENKAVALIER  (Or Everything you want to know about love is at the MET OPERA) Great music and great literature meet on a great stage at the Met Opera’s production of Eugene Onegin on the big screen on April 25, 2017.  The words are Pushkin’s from his  Russian novel-poem.  The music is by Tchaikovsky  for what he termed “lyrical scenes.” Tchaikovsky’s music is forever embedded in our consciousness  with his fantasy ballets like  Nutcracker   and Swan Lake .   Pushkin’s work has provided the inspiration for dozens of musical works, including another famous Russian opera, Boris Godunov.     This team of Tchaikovsky and Pushkin is a sure thing but while there are many scholarly interpretations of Pushkin’s work, there is none that so gets it at its core as this opera. Using the very words from Pushkin’s poem,  Tchaikovsky built the opera through a series of powerful co...
Read more